User talk:Physchim62/Archive 2005
== Phosphorus Halides ==
To celebrate or commemorate your preparation of the new Phosphorus halides article, I have created and uploaded this picture of phosphorus pentafluoride (PF5). It could be made larger or smaller by changing the px width on the edit page. Shall we add this picture to your new article? I reviewed your new Phosphorus halides article and Reference 1 of an article I started called Phosphorus chlorides. Reference 1 in Phosphorus chlorides article says the phosphorus pentachloride (PCl5) is molecular in vapor and liquid phases but ionic in the solid phase as [PCl4+][PCl6-]or similar species. Reference 1 also said that PCl5 in some liquid solvents also has an ionic structure. Because at room temperature PCl5 is a solid, it was a good idea that you put the qualifier in the PCl5 picture I had. Reference 1 also says that PF5 has the trigonal bipyramid geometry in all cases, which agrees with your table.
Another reference I looked at today confirmed the geometry of the POCl3 molecule, so I am leaving that picture as it is in as well as the PCl3 picture. I am continuing to work on the Phosphorus chlorides article whenever I get a chance. User:H Padleckas 05:18, 25 May 2005 (UTC)
== Assessing the WikiProject Chemicals pages ==
Good progress, PC!! Well done. I appreciate the work you do on it. And I mostly agreed with your initial assessments sofar. But don't take it amiss when I think you are too harsh in the 'other important compounds'. May I recommend that you grade several of the 'Stub' into a higher group? And some of those B-Class also may well be considered A-Class. Is there a reason why you are so much stricter in this group than in the others? When in doubt, I graded the articles in favour of the author (just being friendly). User:Wimvandorst 13:59, 2005 May 29 (UTC).
*No, I didn't set out to be harsher to the "Other important compounds" articles, maybe I'm just in a bad mood today! I'm currently preparing a summary of my assessment activity to highlight the issues that have struck me: in the meantime, if you feel that my assessment of any article is unjustified WP:BOLD and change it! :) User:Physchim62 16:45, 29 May 2005 (UTC)
== Axel Gyllenkrok ==
Would you please reconsider your VFD on this page? A user came along and translated the article, and your reason to delete - it not being in English - is no longer valid. User:MacGyverMagic|User talk:MacGyverMagic 15:53, Jun 2, 2005 (UTC)
== re: Transwiki cleanup ==
When you have a minute, I've replied to your comment on Wikipedia:Deletion policy/Reducing VfD load#Transwiki cleanup. User:RossamiUser talk:Rossami 17:31, 2 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== Bikini line ==
I notice that you had added the ''vfd'' boilerplate to Bikini line at 14:52, 11 May 2005 which was 7 minutes following the completion of the first VfD at Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Bikini line. You did not, as far as I can see, complete the nomination by placing it at Wikipedia:Votes for deletion and opening a discussion page. Please see Wikipedia:Deletion policy and Wikipedia:Votes_for_deletion#How_to_list_pages_for_deletion for more information. If you added the boilerplate message mistakenly, please revert it. Cheers, DoubleBlue">User:DoubleBlue (User talk:DoubleBlue 01:13, 8 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== PD-germany ==
Thanks for looking into it! I've edited the template to show it's disputed, for the time being. I suppose that copyrighted images qualify for deletion? And is there a more appropriate tag for those images that turn out ok, or should this tag be reworded? User:Radiant!User_talk:Radiant!>|<">meta:mergist 21:46, Jun 8, 2005 (UTC)
*Cool! Well done! The template is probably going to be deleted as confusing, unless we can find some lawyer-type to properly word it in the next couple of days. Yours, User:Radiant!User_talk:Radiant!>|<">meta:mergist 08:28, Jun 14, 2005 (UTC)
**Oh sorry, I thought you meant it could be deleted (''"Overall, deletion of would not cause WikiChaos, even better would be to improve it to reflect the very law that the current templates cites"'', and since we've been unable to get a lawyer type to do the latter...) What should we do then? Reword the template to state "This image is alleged to be public domain in Germany, even though we aren't sure, and even though German copyright law doesn't necessarily apply in Wikipedia"? (or something less extreme, anyway) User:Radiant!User_talk:Radiant!>|<">meta:mergist 09:57, Jun 15, 2005 (UTC)
== :Category:Terpenes and terpenoids ==
Hi,
I noticed that a duplicate category (:Category:Terpenes) was created recently, which has been Wikipedia:Categories_for_deletion/Log/2005_June_9#Category:Terpenes, because there is already one for terpenes and terpenoids. I made it broader, so that we could include things like menthol. People often refer to terpenoids as terpenes but others might object- I didn't want to start arguments. Should we make''Terpenes'' into a redirect to the established category? We had a similar problem with :Category:Sulphur compounds vs. :Category:Sulfur compounds) resolved in that way. Cheers, User:Walkerma 21:49, 9 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== Sodium sulfate ==
PC, Thanks for moving this page. Are you planning on beefing up this page to Class-A, or should I have a go at it? Cheers User:Walkerma 16:44, 13 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== Good work! ==
Hello, I noticed you've been doing great work on Wikipedia:Pages needing translation into English lately. Thanks for that and keep up the good work! Best regards, User:Sietse Snel 17:32, 18 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== Arsenic trioxide ==
Hi, I wanted to mention that the [http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arsentrioxid German page] on this has a lot of content, it may be worth looking at if your German is better than mine. Also, while you're on a roll, consider doing Bi2O3 as well :) Cheers, User:Walkerma 21:01, 18 Jun 2005 (UTC)
== Hitlerjugend image ==
I never used any template, you are wrong. I put it in the Hitlerjugend article, someone must later have removed it, so it was in use in an article at a point.
== PD-germ ==
Cool! Thanks for the effort. User:Radiant!User_talk:Radiant!>|<">meta:mergist 11:33, Jun 20, 2005 (UTC)
== :Image:Hitlerandchamberlain.jpg
I didn't place that tag, somebody else put it on there. I've changed it to Fair Use. Thanks for the update.--User:naryathegreat | User talk:Naryathegreat 23:49, Jun 20, 2005 (UTC)
== Dale Velzy ==
You may wish to list this article over at Copyright Problems. It's taken from here [http://surfingthemag.com/news/surfing-pulse/velzy_052705/]. User:JamesBurns 06:21, 21 Jun 2005 (UTC)